Coach Jenny started playing lacrosse her freshman year at Holy Trinity High School on Long Island, New York. As a member of the girls’ varsity lacrosse team, she earned the award of All-Long Island in 2001, 2002, and 2003. She was named team captain in both 2002 and 2003. In 2003, Jenny broke the school records for both goals and assists and was named team MVP. Coach Jenny earned a scholarship and went on to play Division I lacrosse at Manhattan College. In 2007, Jenny earned the Jasper Award and was a MAAC All-Academic selection. In 2006, she was a First Team All-MAAC, MAAC All-Tournament, and MAAC All-Academic selection. In 2005, Jenny was named to the second Team All-MAAC and to the MAAC All-Academic Team. In 2004, she earned Rookie of the Week twice. Coach Jenny and her team won the MAAC championship in 2004 and 2005. Coach Jenny also coached girls’ high school lacrosse for 2 teams on Long Island.